Surprise! College Football’s Unexpected Success Stories of 2024
After five weeks of thrilling college football action, the landscape of the sport has shifted dramatically. Teams that were once considered underdogs or afterthoughts are now proudly proclaiming their success, challenging the naysayers who doubted their potential. Among these surprises, Florida State has emerged as a standout, but they are not alone. Let’s dive into the ten teams that have turned heads and defied expectations in the 2024 season.
1. Indiana Hoosiers
Under the leadership of first-year head coach Curt Cignetti, the Indiana Hoosiers have made waves in the Big Ten. Predicted to finish 17th out of 18 teams, with Vegas setting their over/under for wins at a mere 5.5, Cignetti’s bold declarations have sparked both enthusiasm and skepticism. His brash comments, including a memorable jab at rivals Purdue and Michigan, have set the tone for a season that has seen the Hoosiers start 5-0. A standout performance against UCLA, where they won 42-13, showcased their offensive prowess, largely fueled by a roster bolstered by 31 incoming transfers, including MAC Offensive Player of the Year Kurtis Rourke.
2. BYU Cougars
After a disappointing 2023 season, the BYU Cougars have rebounded impressively in their second year in the Big 12. Initially picked to finish 13th, they have started the season 5-0, thanks in large part to a revitalized defense that ranks 16th nationally in yards allowed per play. Quarterback Jake Retzlaff, a former junior college standout, has emerged as a key player, leading the Cougars to significant victories, including a decisive win over Kansas State.
3. Pittsburgh Panthers
The Pittsburgh Panthers have undergone a remarkable transformation under new offensive coordinator Kade Bell. After a dismal 3-9 season in 2023, they have surged to a 4-0 start, defying expectations set by their 13th-place preseason ranking in the ACC. Quarterback Eli Holstein has been a revelation, particularly in clutch moments, while running back Kyle Monangai has consistently delivered strong performances, averaging nearly 150 rushing yards per game.
4. James Madison Dukes
Following the departure of Cignetti to Indiana, the James Madison Dukes faced a challenging offseason. However, under new coach Bob Chesney, they have made headlines by hanging 70 points on North Carolina, thrusting themselves into the College Football Playoff conversation. Quarterback Alonza Barnett III has been a standout, throwing 12 touchdowns to just one interception, while the Dukes’ defense has also made significant strides.
5. UNLV Rebels
The UNLV Rebels have embraced a high-octane offense under offensive coordinator Brennan Marion, despite facing quarterback turnover. With a 4-0 record, they have already secured impressive wins against Big 12 opponents, including Kansas. The Rebels are now in contention for a Group of 5 playoff spot, showcasing resilience amidst challenges, including the departure of key players.
6. Washington State Cougars
In the wake of conference realignment, Washington State has managed to piece together a competitive squad. With a 4-1 record, they have already secured a dramatic victory over rival Washington. Coach Jake Dickert has found success with quarterback John Mateer, whose rushing ability has added a dynamic element to the Cougars’ offense, making them a formidable opponent in their new Mountain West-heavy schedule.
7. Duke Blue Devils
Under new head coach Manny Diaz, the Duke Blue Devils have exceeded expectations, starting the season 5-0 despite significant roster turnover. Their defense has improved dramatically, ranking seventh nationally in yards allowed per play. Key victories, including a comeback win against North Carolina, have solidified their status as a team to watch in the ACC.
8. Illinois Fighting Illini
The Illinois Fighting Illini have surprised many by starting 4-0, a feat not achieved since 2011. Predicted to finish near the bottom of the Big Ten, they have logged impressive wins against Kansas and Nebraska. Quarterback Luke Altmyer has emerged as a key player, throwing for 11 touchdowns and leading the team to competitive performances against top-tier opponents.
9. Colorado Buffaloes
After a dismal previous season, the Colorado Buffaloes have made a remarkable turnaround under head coach Deion Sanders. With a 4-1 record, they are on track for their third bowl game since 2007. Stars like Travis Hunter and Shedeur Sanders have propelled the team, with Sanders ranking sixth nationally in passing yards. The Buffaloes have shown resilience, overcoming flaws in their roster to compete effectively in the Big 12.
10. Arizona State Sun Devils
The Arizona State Sun Devils have quietly put together a solid start to their season, showcasing a balanced attack on both sides of the ball. With a strong emphasis on defense, they have managed to keep opponents at bay while their offense finds its rhythm. This unexpected success has positioned them as a potential contender in the Pac-12, surprising many who had written them off.
As the season progresses, these teams will continue to battle for supremacy, proving that in college football, surprises are always just around the corner. The unexpected success stories of 2024 have not only captivated fans but have also reshaped the narrative of the season, reminding everyone that anything can happen on the gridiron.