Welcome to Part 2 of Our Reader Mailbag
If you missed Part 1, you can catch up here. In this installment, I’ll be diving into some intriguing questions from our readers, including a heartfelt reflection on Johnny Gaudreau. Your inquiries not only fuel my writing but also provide a window into what’s on the minds of hockey fans everywhere.
Reforming the NHL Calendar: A European Perspective
Andrea D. writes from Europe, where national championships are kicking off, and raises an important question about the NHL’s schedule. The current playtime period stretches from mid-September to the end of May, leading to discussions about potential reforms.
Having covered the NHL since the 1980-81 season, I’ve seen the playoffs extend into June, which feels absurd for a winter sport. Ideally, I’d advocate for a shortened training camp, starting the regular season on October 1, and capping the playoffs by May 31. However, many U.S.-based teams prefer a later start to avoid conflicts with baseball playoffs and the NFL season. This reluctance to change means that fans, particularly in Canada and northern U.S. states, are left waiting for a more reasonable schedule.
The Trade Value of Calgary Flames Veterans
Ryan H. raises a compelling question about the Calgary Flames and the potential trade value of players like Jonathan Huberdeau, Blake Coleman, and others amid rumors of unrest among veterans.
In the NHL, contracts that seem impossible to trade often find new homes. Huberdeau, with a hefty $10.5 million cap hit and seven years remaining, would need to return to his previous form—ideally, a point-a-game player—to attract interest. Given his underwhelming performance since joining Calgary, a trade without salary retention seems unlikely.
Coleman, on the other hand, is a different story. At 32, with three years left at $4.9 million, his championship experience makes him an attractive option for contenders. Backlund, despite his age and a recent pay cut to stay with the Flames, might also have value if he seeks a championship elsewhere. Meanwhile, players like Weegar and Kadri have their own unique situations, with Weegar being a vital piece in Calgary’s transition and Kadri potentially useful for a team with a short window to win.
Evaluating a Potential Trade: Darnell Nurse for Seth Jones
Mike C. poses an interesting hypothetical: Should Edmonton consider trading Darnell Nurse for Seth Jones?
Both players are 29 and have similar contracts, but Jones has been logging significantly more ice time. From what I’ve observed, Jones appears to be the more well-rounded defenseman. While Edmonton might jump at the chance for this swap, Chicago would likely require an enticing sweetener to make the deal worthwhile.
Old Cup-Winning Teams: Who Has the Best Chance?
Daniel W. asks which “old” Cup-winning team might recapture their former glory. While teams like Washington, Pittsburgh, and Los Angeles seem unlikely to return to the top, I wouldn’t count out Tampa Bay just yet. With key players like Andrei Vasilevskiy and Nikita Kucherov still in their prime, the Lightning could make a strong push in the coming seasons, unlike the other teams whose windows appear to have closed.
The Future of NHL Expansion
John F. raises a thought-provoking question about the NHL’s future expansion and the possibility of relegation.
While the idea of relegation has been floated, it’s hard to envision it becoming a reality in North American sports. As for expansion, I believe the NHL could reach 40 teams eventually, but not without a pause after hitting 36. Cities like Atlanta, Houston, and Portland are likely candidates for future teams, though Quebec City remains a sentimental favorite for many fans.
Gary Bettman’s Succession Plan
Michael H. inquires about Gary Bettman’s succession plan. While Bettman hasn’t publicly discussed it, I suspect he’ll step down around 2027, leading to a search for his replacement. It’s likely that current deputy commissioner Bill Daly will be considered, but the NHL may also look for fresh perspectives from candidates who are currently off the radar.
Remembering Johnny Gaudreau
D.J. N. asks for memories of Johnny Gaudreau, who tragically passed away recently.
Having covered Gaudreau during his time in Calgary, I remember him as a vibrant presence in the locker room—someone who could brighten anyone’s day. His charm and charisma made him a beloved figure among teammates and fans alike.
One standout moment was during his contract negotiations in 2016. Gaudreau expressed a desire to return to the ice rather than hold out for a better deal, showcasing his passion for the game. His natural talent and work ethic were evident, and he often spoke about his aspirations beyond hockey, including a potential career as a gym teacher.
Gaudreau’s kindness extended beyond the rink; he once designed his summer home to accommodate a cousin with a disability, reflecting his genuine character. His passing leaves a profound void in the hockey community, and the upcoming NHL season will undoubtedly feel different without him.
As we continue to navigate the complexities of the NHL, your questions and insights remain invaluable. Thank you for your engagement, and I look forward to addressing more topics in the future.